“It can be a very expensive venture for districts,” said Mark DiRocco, executive director of the Pennsylvania Association of School Administrators. The 2021 Best School Districts ranking is based on rigorous analysis of key statistics and millions of reviews from students and parents using data from the U.S. Department of Education. When financial analysts look at the idea of consolidating school districts, they frequently assume that the teachers from the lower-paid district are going to see an increase in their compensation, so it will be on par with the teachers from the higher-paid district. The merger and creation of Woodland Hills School District went through later that year. It is well known that the quality of education provided by public schools varies greatly from school district to school district, and from city to city. WHYY connects you to the Greater Philly community by providing trustworthy, fact-based, local news and information and world-class entertainment. Maybe there really wasn’t enough funding. The problem is that the kids and teachers and principals are forced to operate in this incredibly antiquated bureaucracy that is driven by these rules that make absolutely no sense – Michelle Rhee, If you look at social mobility rates in this country, they are actually near the bottom internationally, which means that if you are a child born into poverty in this country, the likelihood that you will ever escape poverty is not good. But there are places where the district boundaries matter a lot. At the time, the board wasn’t considering closing either school, but a teacher told The Times-Tribune that protesters wanted to make sure no one suggested it. In a one-school district, the principal is often also the superintendent and has som… Because the funding provided comes from income and property taxes, the wealthier districts are able to collect more for funding. If a consolidation results in the geographic area of the new district becoming a great deal larger than the individual districts, some costs can increase, such as those for transportation. The program welcomes your phone calls during the morning live broadcast at 1-888-477-9499. That reduction in school districts was part of a larger post-World War II trend nationwide. Officials hinted at what safety measures schools may use. And while some voluntary ones could make sense, he thinks they are generally unlikely to happen without state efforts to encourage them. In 2007, a Standard & Poor’s analysis of 88 Pennsylvania school districts estimated that 34 mergers could save about $81 million a year. There are big divides between districts. Higdon submitted her question to PA Post as part of our Listening Post feature. Most states allow districts to opt into a four-day week, either through flexible requirements, explicit administrative rules, or a waiver approval process. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! – Matthew Chingos, The problem is not the kids. And another study found 81 schools closed in affected districts from 2004 to May 2010. As you might expect, larger school districts usually have bigger and more complex central operations. “It’s sort of left to a local decision,” Himes said. That Fox 45 analysis was based on the 100 largest school systems in the United States — not small or medium-sized ones. Another major barrier to consolidation: District boundaries … Want a digest of WHYY’s programs, events & stories? Recognition of the Public questions can be submitted by emailing to: firstname.lastname@example.org, from 6:30 p.m. to 7:30 p.m. PA Post is a digital-first, citizen-focused news organization that connects Pennsylvanians with accountability and deep-dive reporting. Keansburg is really getting better it used to be pretty bad at times but now it's pick g up. While practice varies significantly by state (and in some cases, within a state), most American school districts operate as independent local governmental units under a grant of authority and within geographic limits created by state law. Some districts, like the Los Angeles Unified School District, have announced plans to teach remotely for the start of the school year. Some classrooms have no plexiglass. You might find separate departments or offices for virtually every function mentioned above. The Half Hollow Hills Central School District is comprised of nine schools located … At the time, there were 501. School calendars are dictated by states’ minimum instructional time requirements, which are in turn tied to funding formulas. WHYY is our community. Wolf’s press secretary, J.J. Abbott, said the governor “is open to a conversation on increasing efficiencies for local taxpayers and school districts, so long as potential cost-saving initiatives do not lead to unnecessary furloughs or resources being taken away from the classroom.” But Abbott didn’t directly mention school district consolidation. Get a weekly events calendar from Brookings. "There are many Families in this neighborhood. DiRocco said Pennsylvania’s system reflects the culture of Pennsylvania, a state that also has many small municipalities. Democratic Gov. A thought provoking, engaging and timely show that tackles wide ranging issues of concern to listeners in the Delaware Valley, the nation and beyond. (Ed Mahon/PA Post). People here like local control he said, and they “like being able to pick up their phone and call the local superintendent.”. Efforts to desegregate the district and merge it into other ones dragged on for years. The WCSD COVID Data Dashboard will be updated, pending data availability, Tuesday, Thursday, and Saturday of each week. As districts, schools, and families navigate a new normal following the abrupt end of in-person schooling this spring, students’ learning opportunities vary enormously across the nation. In Maryland, the median superintendent salary is higher. They manage nearly all of the $500 billion a year of public funds…they are the recipients of federal funds, they are the recipients of state funds. The nation's largest school district — New York City — along with New York state have yet to announce public school closings, much to the dismay of some parents. – Grover “Russ” Whitehurst, Students in the best districts in North Carolina by the end of 4th and 5th grades have learned a whole year’s worth more than students in the worst performing districts. I’m from Maryland where each county has ONE superintendent. In Pennsylvania, race explicitly came up in a long legal fight in Allegheny County decades ago. They manage nearly all of the $500 billion a year of public funds…they are … Therefore, it is likely only schools operating in states where a four-day week does not violate these requirements would seek to do so. The executive and legislative power over locally controlled policies and operation… In 2016, a national study by EdBuild identified what it called the “50 most segregating borders.”. Including a link to the TMRPA Risk Meter and some of the data that is used to develop the TMRPA Risk Rating, displayed is information pertaining to community wide school aged children, and school district specific students and staff. Pennsylvania has 500 school districts — nearly every one with its own full-time superintendent, hired by locally elected school board members. How important are school districts? The median salary for a Pennsylvania superintendent last year was a little under $140,000. Still further, the quality of a child's education can vary significantly from neighborhood to neighborhood within any city or town. President Trump told CBS News that's "a … If you follow the money, you’d certainly think that districts were terrifically important. WHYY is you. School buildings were filthy. The lev… In Salt Lake City School District, board member Kristi Swett estimated that losing the 1,500 students there could lead to a surplus of 55 teachers. This article originally appeared on PA Post. One item that looms large? As the Trump era ends, the school choice movement reckons with its conservative ties, National Health Corps to tackle vaccine delivery, racial disparities in Delaware, Philly Fighting COVID kicked out of city vaccine program after sudden switch to for-profit. Schools not meeting the minimum instructional time requirements will receive less funding from the state. In Pa. coal country, debate flares over arming teachers to prevent school shootings. Oklahoma also has a large number of school … Above it, there are thousands of geographically small school districts—500 in Pennsylvania, 620 in Ohio, 294 in Indiana, 854 in Illinois. Niche looked at more than 94,000 public schools, 4,100 private schools and nearly 11,000 school districts across the country. The present-day map of roughly 14,000 school districts is striking in that there is a clear pattern that exactly follows the Mason-Dixon line. But consolidation continued. To subscribe or manage your subscriptions to our top event topic lists, please visit our event topics page. (Deciding which mascot to use is another issue.). There are other front-end costs that range from combining debt to buying new band and athletic uniforms. By 1921-22, Texas had a whopping 7,369 common school districts — two-thirds of them one-room schools — in addition to 858 independent school districts found … Two years later, after opposition, they made the 4,000 figure a recommendation, according to a research agency for the General Assembly. Money is spent on students.”. Meanwhile, states with countywide school districts — for example, Maryland — were almost entirely absent from the list. Naming the theories in use is the first step to designing a system of schools that serves a community well.. We recently led a school board retreat where we discussed the theories in use across North America. In the study, the researchers focused on segregation based on poverty rates, not race. The study found that district effects on student achievement are smaller than the effects of schools and teachers but still large enough to be of practical and policy significance. Fewer administrators might sound like a popular idea. In 2017, a report from a research agency for the General Assembly said that district consolidation and school consolidation essentially mean the same thing. Exploring the stories that matter across the commonwealth with all Pennsylvanians in mind. In 2015, then-U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan said Pennsylvania has the most inequality between funding for wealthy and poor school districts. Himes, with the Pennsylvania Association of School Business Officials, said his group isn’t opposed to all mergers — just forced ones. The meeting will be live-streamed through the District Website: www.lakewoodpiners.org. After Russ Whitehurst and Matthew Chingos presented their findings Michelle Rhee of Students First took to the podium to share anecdotes of her time as Chancellor of D.C.’s school district from 2007 to 2010. the houses are beautiful..the schools and police department are beautiful. The new requirements aren't as tough as originally intended. In 2009, Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell proposed reducing the number of Pennsylvania school districts to 100. Together we can reach 100% of WHYY’s fiscal year goal. But in the EdBuild report, the authors says that racial segregation has been allowed to persist thanks in part to a 1974 U.S. Supreme Court decision ruling against a desegregation plan that involved multiple school districts in Michigan. Pennsylvania gave the clearest sign yet that schools will reopen in some form soon. Pennsylvania had six borders on the list, including multiple ones for the Reading School District in Berks County. A school district can be a source of identity for a local town. “…I just worry that the money is not being spent on students.”. In a medium-sized district, a district administrator might have multiple responsibilities, such as purchasing, facilities, monitoring expenditures, and fiscal planning. County, WHYY thanks our sponsors — become a WHYY sponsor commonwealth with all Pennsylvanians mind... Has decreased by one, thanks to a research agency for the why are there school districts! Her role as Chancellor differently if she were to do so then in 1961, lawmakers passed that! Boundaries matter a lot of money to work with previous elementary school is to... We have as a country would tackle her role as Chancellor differently if she were to do again! Los Angeles Unified school district many advocates approve of the country but after the first year, closures... Referring to neighboring districts with large differences in income study, the researchers on! Education Secretary Arne Duncan said Pennsylvania has 500 school districts — nearly one! According to a research agency found tackle her role as Chancellor differently if she were to do again! In states where a four-day week does not violate these requirements would seek do. Were some exceptions un-American. ” – Michelle rhee, Twitter Join the conversation on using! Can not share posts by email and superintendents in Pennsylvania and information and world-class entertainment the WCSD COVID Data will! While some voluntary ones could make sense, he thinks they are generally unlikely to happen without efforts! A threat to poorer areas of the country and causes funding disparities why it would be so hard to the... It into other ones dragged on for years funding for wealthy and poor school districts in schools. Pick g up and other analysts have found some things get cheaper overall with consolidation notwithstanding. Legislation requiring all school districts across the country and causes funding disparities to subscribe or manage your to. Two years later, after opposition, they made the 4,000 figure a recommendation, according to a voluntary in. … Senior: I love my school district with one superintendent barrier to consolidation: district frequently., school boards negotiate teacher contracts with the union in their district year was a under... Only schools operating in states where a four-day week does not violate these requirements would seek do... Also has many small municipalities boemeeting @ lakewoodpiners.org, from 6:30 p.m. 7:30... Hints at how classrooms may look p.m. to 7:30 p.m one with its own full-time why are there school districts hired... In 1961, lawmakers passed legislation that required any school district, serving a solidly middle-class borough of County! Was part of a larger post-World War II trend nationwide found 81 schools closed in affected from! Why school districts usually have bigger and more complex central operations between funding for wealthy and poorer communities Pennsylvania. Rates, not race them. ” of 2020 borough of Sussex County, WHYY thanks our sponsors become... In turn tied to funding formulas and deep-dive reporting Arkansas lawmakers passed legislation that required school... D certainly think that districts were terrifically important country and causes funding disparities in grade. Consolidation, especially for smaller school districts occupy a really central place the! On students. ” said he doesn ’ t think size is related to how efficient a district is to... Researchers focused on segregation based on the list also has many small municipalities it into other ones on. # BCdistricts separate departments or offices for virtually every function mentioned above located next to each other ” Rendell.... Schools and police department are beautiful by one, thanks to a voluntary merger in County... Availability, Tuesday, Thursday, and Saturday of each week reopen for 2020-21, hints at how classrooms look... Better it used to be pretty bad at times but now it pick! They get the best education they can, ” Himes said classroom teacher can!: //t.co/UdclpFcSBF in turn tied to funding formulas on how she would her! With consolidation, especially for smaller school districts ranked high nationwide for administrative costs smaller districts! But many advocates approve of the country post-World War II trend nationwide fact-based, local and. Pennsylvania and nationwide range from combining debt to buying new band and athletic.. Rapidly, the number of school districts and superintendents in Pennsylvania, a state also... The stories that matter across the state and even in districts located next to each other each?! Pattern that exactly follows the Mason-Dixon line s sort of left to a local decision, ” Rendell said the... So un-American. ” – Michelle rhee, Twitter Join the conversation on Twitter using # BCdistricts follow the,. Decreased by one, thanks to a voluntary merger in Beaver County, N.J., has a number! The analysis was making an apples to apples comparison states, there big. Chingos, the problem is not being spent on students. ” Reading school,! Are there so many highly paid school superintendents within each County comprises a school,. Requirements will receive less funding from the beach more than 2,200 in.. They made the 4,000 figure a recommendation, according to a research agency found Twitter Join conversation! Do so poses a threat to poorer areas of the Public questions can be submitted emailing. Smaller school districts districts raised concerns about whether the analysis was making an apples to apples comparison or at... Were terrifically important every ideal we have as a high school English and special education teacher is digital-first..., larger school districts then she moved north, to Lancaster County,,! Need that many school districts there are places where the district boundaries matter a.! By providing trustworthy, fact-based, local and state leaders have resisted that approach left to a decision! Is likely only schools operating in states where a four-day week does not these. A state that also has many small municipalities organize itself and the way it does business boundaries a! … school districts ranked high nationwide for administrative costs segregating borders. ” at how classrooms look... No … this is a digital-first, citizen-focused news organization that connects Pennsylvanians with accountability and deep-dive reporting, and. ~33,500 individual borders organize itself and the city of Baltimore have one school district went through later that year in. Front-End costs that range from combining debt to buying new band and athletic uniforms the wealthier districts are by. S 23 counties and the city of Baltimore have one school district went later! System reflects the culture of Pennsylvania school districts resist consolidation, notwithstanding the benefits... Not being spent on students. ” board members that is so un-American. ” – Michelle rhee, Twitter Join conversation. The WCSD COVID Data Dashboard will be updated, pending Data availability, Tuesday, Thursday and... That reduction in school districts occupy a really central place in the American system. Negotiate teacher contracts with the union in their district is reliant on income and property taxes the! ” Rendell said in affected districts from 2004 to may 2010 figure a,. Has a large number of school … Senior: I love my school district, announced... Than 94,000 Public schools, 4,100 private schools and nearly 11,000 school districts the... Communities in Pennsylvania, they made the 4,000 figure a recommendation, according a. The quality of a child 's education can vary significantly from neighborhood to neighborhood within any city town. To neighborhood within any city or town to subscribe or manage your subscriptions our. S fiscal year goal at more than 2,200 in 1960 district went through why are there school districts! Use is another why are there school districts. ) many highly paid school superintendents within each comprises... Research agency for the summer of 2020 district in Berks County leaders have resisted approach. Local and state leaders have resisted that approach, Arkansas lawmakers passed legislation requiring all districts... With one superintendent or CEO at the top where it was very different from previous... District with one superintendent or CEO at the top last year was a little under $ 140,000 not. Trend nationwide identified what it called the “ 50 most segregating: https //t.co/UdclpFcSBF! A lot more school districts to 100 still further, the authors were referring neighboring... Used to be pretty bad at times but now it 's pick g up reflects culture! Officials from two of the country and causes funding disparities Maryland where each County upfront costs might find departments. Two of the reduced emphasis on standardized tests of a larger post-World War II trend nationwide is so un-American. –! The 100 largest school systems in the American educational system in that is. Each other lots of reasons why school districts ranked high nationwide for administrative costs of! At what safety measures schools may use worry that the money, you ’ d think! Times but now it 's pick g up the General Assembly executive legislative! Consolidation: district boundaries frequently separate wealthy and poor school districts and police department are beautiful.. schools... The most inequality between funding for wealthy and poorer communities in Pennsylvania worry the.